POWERLESS TO SAVE POWER HOUSES?
Few historic buildings made a bigger contribution to the modern age than the power houses that provided the first mains electricity. You might imagine something of this revolution would be worth saving, but it's not that easy.
|
|
In the grounds of Osborne House, fronting the main road, sits a quaint transformer house, built in 1903 to supply power to Osborne Cadet College. It converting 240 volts to the 105 required by the college and housed a dynamo for emergencies. The building still houses a transformer. It is owned by Scottish and Southern Energy and they recently decided to demolish it. When this was discovered, some in the community protested to the IW Conservation Dept. They were assured that English Heritage had the building listed as within the curtilage of Osborne House and it could not be taken down without planning permission. Some months later the Conservation Dept announced that the original assumption of listing had been in error and the building would now come down. This unfortunate news was presented as a fait accompli, giving the community no chance to make representations to SSE or English Heritage.
The destruction seems unnecessary. If SSE don't want the building it would certainly be of use to the community or local business. They could relocate the transformer nearby. Had the Conservation Dept, English Heritage and SSE got together, they could have surely made alternative arrangements.
The transformer house was originally on line from Newport power station, via Cowes substation. The now vacant Newport power station has also become an issue. The developer is appealing against the council's decision to refuse the most recent planning application. The application proposed replacing the body of the power station with a block of flats, while retaining the familiar facade. It was refused on a range of criteria, not least the unsuitability of this type of development for the quay area. In seeking to retain the facade, the developer was responding to the council's historical assessment of the building, which places emphasis on the facade's skyline impact.
In fact the soul of the building is the elegant turbine hall. Although it has suffered neglect, it is not beyond imaginative conversion for use in a number of business or leisure applications, leaving plenty of opportunity for additional development. The turbine hall is fundamental to the purpose of the building and without it preservation would be superficial. Hopefully the appeal will fail and the council will take the opportunity to apply a more professional evaluation to their preservation criteria.
|
| |
At left, Osborne transformer house, due for demolition. Above, Newport power station awaits the outcome of a planning appeal.
|
|
|